Good question. Navigational is the most protected, but not entirely safe.
Why navigational is more protected:
User intent is clear: “I want to go to [Brand].” AI’s job is to help them do that, not provide alternatives.
How AI handles navigational:
“HubSpot login” → AI provides link to HubSpot login page
“Amazon pricing” → AI directs to Amazon, doesn’t answer differently
Where it’s still different from traditional:
AI can add context:
“HubSpot pricing” might get:
- Link to pricing page (navigational fulfilled)
- Summary of pricing tiers (AI addition)
- Comparison to competitors (AI addition)
AI can influence:
Even in navigational, AI might mention:
- Alternative options
- Considerations
- Warnings or cautions
What’s actually at risk:
Pure navigational (login, homepage): Very safe
Brand + topic (brand + pricing, brand + reviews): Somewhat affected
Brand + comparison: Definitely affected
The gradient:
More specific brand intent = more protected
Brand + informational element = more AI influence