GEO strategy

German SEO and GEO Agencies Compared: 2026 Benchmark

100 prompts, 300 AI answers, 936 Google results and 131 domains: an evidence-based comparison of German SEO and GEO agencies with AmICited and Ahrefs.

German SEO and GEO Agencies Compared: 2026 Benchmark
Germany · 100 AI prompts 61 min read 7 questions answered

Every German agency on our shortlist now sells “visibility in ChatGPT”. All 20 list pages about GEO, KI-Sichtbarkeit or AI search in their own sitemaps. The harder question for a buyer is which of them AI engines actually name when someone in Germany asks for an agency, and where the engines get those names from.

We measured it. On 12 November 2026, AmICited ran 100 German-language prompts targeted at Germany on ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode, and recorded which agencies each answer named and which websites it cited. Ahrefs supplied organic traffic, keywords and backlinks for 131 domains. We also crawled each agency’s homepage and sitemaps and read their published case studies and prices. This article documents the method and what the evidence supports, agency by agency.

Snapshot date: 12 November 2026. This is a one-time observation, not a live ranking. Every traffic figure labelled Ahrefs is a modelled estimate, not an agency’s analytics. The experiment targets Germany and German-language prompts. It is the third country edition after our Slovak and Austrian comparisons, and it uses the same method so the editions can be compared.

Key Takeaways

  • Suchhelden was named in the most AI answers (56 of 300), ahead of Claneo (35), Seokratie (28), Netzbekannt (21), Aufgesang and Hecht ins Gefecht (17 each), in AmICited’s one-time Germany snapshot of 12 November 2026.
  • The engines disagree. Google AI Overviews named Suchhelden in 29 of 100 answers; ChatGPT named Claneo (16) and Netzbekannt (15) more often than Suchhelden (13).
  • Agencies’ own “best agency” lists feed the answers. Hecht ins Gefecht was cited in 16 answers, 13 of them through its own list of the most visible SEO agencies, which ranks itself first. Suchhelden’s own list of the best German SEO agencies was cited in 9.
  • Google barely shows agencies for these prompts. Suchhelden appeared in the classic Google results of 8 of 100 prompts, more than any other shortlisted agency; Sortlist appeared in 36 and werbeagentur.de in 25.
  • SEO-Küche has the most German organic traffic (about 57,000 visits a month, Ahrefs), but most of it lands on glossary and blog pages. Among agency-service sites, Suchhelden leads with about 26,600.
  • Directories shape ChatGPT’s answers. agenturtipp.de was cited in 60 AI answers, 44 of them from ChatGPT, and Dr. Web’s agency comparisons in 39.

How we ran the German benchmark

The brief was simple: find out whom a German buyer sees when they ask Google or an AI assistant for an SEO, GEO or online-marketing agency, and what that buyer can verify about those suppliers before signing. We fixed the questions, sources and comparison rules before looking at any answers.

Pick the reference domain with Ahrefs

Pull German SERPs for 15 agency keywords, then compare the candidate agencies on German organic traffic and check where that traffic lands. Suchhelden led among agency-service sites.

Research short German keywords

Select 60 German phrases from Ahrefs Keywords Explorer by relevance and German search volume (400 to 39,000 searches a month). No brand names.

Add short buyer questions

Write 40 short questions about supplier choice, prices, cities (Berlin, Munich, Hamburg, Cologne, Frankfurt), Bavaria, ecommerce, B2B and AI visibility. None names an agency.

Run a one-time AmICited experiment

Country Germany, schedule one-time, engines ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode. Every prompt ran once per engine, with classic Google results recorded alongside.

Build the competitor registry

Register 100 German agencies with their domains, then add the 30 agencies the engines named that the registry missed.

Measure the agencies' own domains in Ahrefs

German, Austrian and worldwide organic traffic, keywords, keywords in the top 3, DR and referring domains for 131 hosts.

Inspect public sites

Homepage HTML, robots.txt and bounded XML sitemap inventories for all 131 hosts, plus imprints, service pages, case studies and price pages for the shortlist. Lighthouse mobile lab tests for the 20 shortlisted homepages.

Interpret and publish the underlying data

Keep mentions apart from citations, Google from AI, and supplier claims from independent evidence. Every language edition comes from the same frozen dataset.

Tools and evidence used

Tool or sourceRole in the analysis
AmICited.com and its MCPPrompt configuration, AI answers, brand mentions, cited sources, classic Google results, competitor registry, authority and llms.txt views
Ahrefs MCPReference-domain selection, German keyword volumes, German, Austrian and worldwide organic estimates, DR and referring domains
Public HTML, robots.txt and XML sitemapsIndependent observations of availability, metadata, inventories and declared modification dates
Chrome UX Report via AmICitedReal-user LCP, INP and CLS (p75) for the tracked domains
Lighthouse (mobile lab)One machine’s lab measurement of the 20 shortlisted homepages, kept separate from field data
Official agency pagesImprints, services, published prices, case studies and claimed results, quoted as claims, not verified outcomes

The whole pipeline ran through the AmICited and Ahrefs MCP connections, so every number in this article can be traced to a stored export.

What buyers should take away

For AI recommendations, Suchhelden leads clearly, named in 56 of 300 answers and cited as a source in 39. Claneo and Seokratie form a second group with 35 and 28 answers. Netzbekannt, Aufgesang and Hecht ins Gefecht follow with 17–21, although none of the three was in our original registry.

For classic Google visibility on the buyer’s own queries, no agency stands out: Google showed mostly directories and comparison portals for these prompts. Suchhelden (8 prompts), seowerk (6), DREIKON and SUMAX (5 each) appeared most often. For organic traffic on their own German websites, Suchhelden, Online Solutions Group, Löwenstark, Seokratie and DREIKON lead among agency-service sites; SEO-Küche has more, mostly from content pages.

For transparent prices, adMates, SaphirSolution, Löwenstark and JSH Marketing publish starting prices or price ranges. For published proof, SUMAX, Ostend Digital, JSH Marketing, SaphirSolution and Seokratie publish case studies with numbers. Those numbers are supplier claims, not audited results.

This comparison does not rank agency quality
Being named by ChatGPT does not prove good client work, and a weak agency website does not prove poor client work. We separate observed visibility of the supplier’s own brand and domain, published client-result claims and facts that public evidence cannot establish. An agency can be excellent for a Bavarian manufacturer and absent from a Berlin-focused prompt set.

Method: three layers of evidence

Layer 1: AI answers. AmICited sent each of the 100 prompts once to ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode, with Germany as the target country, and stored the answer text, the brands it named and the URLs it cited. All 300 runs completed. 291 returned answer text (nine AI Overviews were empty), and 269 named at least one brand. Classic Google results for the same 100 queries were recorded alongside, 936 organic results in total. They are reported separately and never counted as AI sources.

Layer 2: the agencies’ own domains. Ahrefs batch analysis (subdomains, both protocols, average volume mode) for all 131 hosts, for Germany, Austria and worldwide. Ahrefs traffic is an estimate built from rankings and search volumes, so it is useful for comparison but is not a visit count.

Layer 3: public websites. A bounded crawl of each homepage, robots.txt and up to 12 sitemap files or 50,000 URLs per host, plus imprint checks and up to five official pages per shortlisted agency. Lighthouse ran three mobile lab passes per shortlisted homepage from one machine.

Two ways of counting AI visibility

We report two numbers and keep them apart:

  • AI answers naming the agency. For each of the 300 answers, does it name the agency at all? Several mentions in one answer count once, so the maximum is 300. Brand spellings are merged to one domain (“HECHT INS GEFECHT” and “Hecht ins Gefecht”, or “Online Solutions Group (OSG)” and “Online Solutions Group GmbH”), using an automatic key plus a hand-checked alias list. Unresolved spellings are not credited to anyone.
  • AI answers citing the agency’s website. Does the answer link to a URL on the agency’s host? Again, one per answer, maximum 300.

AmICited’s dashboard also shows its own mention counts (Suchhelden 54, Claneo 35, Seokratie 28 after merging aliases). They follow the same order but use AmICited’s definitions and list only the top 50 brands, so we show them as a secondary column.

A one-time run is not a trend

Every prompt ran once per engine on 12 November 2026. Asked again, ChatGPT may name different agencies. The value of 300 answers is breadth across many questions, not a stable position for any single question. A buyer or agency that wants a trend needs recurring prompts; see how to build a prompt library for AI visibility tracking.

Which agencies AI names most often

AI answers naming the agency (of 300)
Suchhelden 56
Claneo 35
Seokratie 28
Netzbekannt 21
Aufgesang 17
Hecht ins Gefecht 17
SUMAX 16
DREIKON 15
Online Solutions Group 15
SUCHMEISTEREI 14

ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode, 100 prompts each. Shortlist only. Alias spellings merged.

Source: AmICited one-time Germany snapshot, 12 Nov 2026

Suchhelden is the clearest AI winner. It was named in 56 answers, 60% more than the next agency, and by all three engines: 29 times by AI Overviews, 14 by AI Mode and 13 by ChatGPT. The Osnabrück agency says it has worked “seit 2012” for “über 1.000 Kund:innen”, and its founders have written a book on GEO.

Claneo and Seokratie come next, with different engine profiles. Claneo was ChatGPT’s most-named agency (16 answers) and AI Overviews named it 15 times, but AI Mode only 4. Seokratie is spread more evenly: 7 ChatGPT, 11 AI Overviews and 10 AI Mode answers.

AmICited’s overall figures for Suchhelden: 38% prompt visibility, a 3.7% share of voice and an average position of 2.8 when named. The share-of-voice denominator includes 1,466 brand mentions, among them platforms such as Google, Semrush and Sortlist, so it is not German market share.

Agencies the registry missed

The engines also named agencies that were not among our 100 registered competitors, and some of them are among the most-named agencies in the study. We measured 30 of them afterwards. Netzbekannt (21 answers), Aufgesang and Hecht ins Gefecht (17 each), seosupport (12) and SaphirSolution (10) were named often enough to enter the shortlist; all five have a German imprint.

Some have almost no organic footprint. Specht GmbH was named in 9 answers with an Ahrefs DR of 3 and an estimated 7 German visits a month. SEO Erfolg (8 answers) and DTILE (6) show no measurable German organic traffic at all. AI naming can follow other signals, such as directory profiles, reviews or third-party lists, as much as it follows domain size. We describe this association; we don’t claim it as a cause.

Mentions are not citations: which websites become AI sources?

For each answer, we count a host once even if the answer cites several URLs from it. The maximum is 300.

40 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
agenturtipp.de60other source
google.com53other source
drweb.de39other source
suchhelden.de39registry agency
sortlist.de36other source
youtube.com31other source
omr.com25other source
evergreen.media21registry agency
feedbax.de16other source
hechtinsgefecht.de16AI-named agency, not in registry
dreikon.de14registry agency
sumax.de12registry agency
seo-kueche.de11registry agency
agencies.semrush.com10other source
claneo.com10registry agency
selbstaendig-im-netz.de10other source
deutschlands-experten.de9other source
handelsblatt.com9other source
seowerk.de8registry agency
suchmeisterei.de8registry agency
ucentric-media.de8registry agency
admates.de7registry agency
agenturfinder.com7other source
columbus-interactive.de7other source
de.wikipedia.org7other source
onlinesolutionsgroup.de7registry agency
an-digital.com6AI-named agency, not in registry
bvdw.org6other source
eom.de6AI-named agency, not in registry
jsh.marketing6registry agency
marketinginstitut.biz6other source
matthiasklenk.de6other source
adpoint.de5registry agency
aufgesang.de5AI-named agency, not in registry
connex-werbeagentur.de5other source
deine-seo-agentur.de5other source
developers.google.com5other source
ibusiness.de5other source
ionos.de5other source
semtrix.de5registry agency

The most-cited agency pages are agencies’ own rankings of agencies. Hecht ins Gefecht was cited in 16 answers, 13 of them through one page, “Die 10 besten SEO-Agenturen in Deutschland 2026”, which puts Hecht ins Gefecht in first place and Suchhelden second. Suchhelden’s most-cited page is its own “Beste SEO-Agenturen Deutschland 2026” list (9 answers), which starts with Suchhelden. DREIKON’s comparison of the best SEO agencies (5 answers) ranks DREIKON first and says so in a transparency note, and SEO-Küche’s top-10 list of SEO and GEO agencies (2 answers) starts with SEO-Küche. Engines use these self-published rankings as sources. A buyer should read them as marketing by an interested party.

Directories matter even more. agenturtipp.de was cited in 60 answers, 44 of them from ChatGPT, mostly through its city and GEO-agency lists. Dr. Web’s agency comparisons (39 answers), Sortlist (36), OMR Reviews (25) and Feedbax (16) follow. DREIKON’s own ranking scores agencies by their agenturtipp.de reviews, which shows how closely these sources are linked.

google.com is a top “source” for a technical reason: 177 of its cited URLs are Google’s internal searchviewer links in AI Mode answers. We keep it in the data but don’t read it as a website preference.

Each AI engine picks differently

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study132914
Claneoclaneo.com16154
Seokratieseokratie.de71110
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de1542
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de881
Aufgesangaufgesang.de782
SUMAXsumax.de3121
DREIKONdreikon.de357
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de753
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de635
morefiremore-fire.com526
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing633
seosupportseosupport.de426
adMatesadmates.de173
Semtrixsemtrix.de632
seowerkseowerk.de163
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de712
Ostend Digitalostend.digital204
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de130
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com111

The three engines behave like three different advisers:

ChatGPTGoogle AI OverviewsGoogle AI Mode
Brands named per answer (median)654
Answers naming at least one shortlisted agency51 / 10057 / 10043 / 100
Source links recorded472678462
Of which on registry agency sites4118485
Of which on google.com940143
Most-named shortlisted agencyClaneo (16)Suchhelden (29)Suchhelden (14)

ChatGPT names the most brands per answer but rarely links to agency websites: only 41 of its 472 source links point to registry agencies. It leans on directories and comparison portals, above all agenturtipp.de. AI Overviews links most often to agency sites, including their own ranking pages, and that is where Suchhelden’s lead is largest. AI Mode names the fewest agencies and links mostly to Google’s own surfaces.

A buyer who asks only one assistant sees only one of these shortlists. An agency that reports “AI visibility” without naming the engine is hiding most of the story. That is why AmICited tracks each engine separately; see the AI rank tracker.

Google rankings and AI answers don’t match

For every prompt, AmICited also recorded the classic Google organic results. Comparing them with the AI answers shows how little the two channels agree in this market.

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study861
seowerkseowerk.de621
DREIKONdreikon.de551
SUMAXsumax.de533
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de422
Seokratieseokratie.de411
Claneoclaneo.com411
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com206
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de211
adMatesadmates.de221
Semtrixsemtrix.de213
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing211
seosupportseosupport.de205
Ostend Digitalostend.digital112
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de00—
morefiremore-fire.com00—
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de00—
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de00—
Aufgesangaufgesang.de00—
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de00—
Classic Google results vs AI answers naming the agency
Suchhelden · Google 8
Suchhelden · AI answers 56
Claneo · Google 4
Claneo · AI answers 35
seowerk · Google 6
seowerk · AI answers 10
Netzbekannt · Google 0
Netzbekannt · AI answers 21

Google: prompts (of 100) where the agency's site appeared in the recorded organic results. AI: answers (of 300) naming the agency.

Source: AmICited one-time Germany snapshot, 12 Nov 2026

Google shows directories; the AI engines name agencies. For these 100 prompts, Google’s organic results were dominated by Sortlist (36 prompts), werbeagentur.de (25), OMR (19) and agenturtipp.de (16). Suchhelden appeared in 8 result sets, 6 of them in the top three, and leads both channels among the shortlist; only Evergreen Media, the Austrian control, appeared more often (10). Netzbekannt never appeared in a recorded Google result but was named in 21 AI answers, 15 of them by ChatGPT. seowerk shows the opposite pattern: second-most Google result sets (6) but only 10 AI answers.

In the Austrian edition, the reference agency appeared in 32 of 100 Google result sets; here the leader appears in 8. For an agency in Germany, that means being listed and reviewed on the portals Google shows is part of being found, in both channels.

Why prompt selection changes the ranking

Short keywords (“seo agentur”) and buyer questions (“Welche SEO Agentur in Köln ist empfehlenswert?”) are different measurements. We compared the shortlist’s ranking in the two prompt groups:

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study301261
Claneoclaneo.com26292
Seokratieseokratie.de19392
Aufgesangaufgesang.de154218
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de13585
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de126512
DREIKONdreikon.de126316
SUMAXsumax.de118512
morefiremore-fire.com109316
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de91069
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de71177
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing61269
seowerkseowerk.de612414
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de612414
seosupportseosupport.de41585
adMatesadmates.de41577
Semtrixsemtrix.de21792
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de217218
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com217120
Ostend Digitalostend.digital02069

Suchhelden is first in both groups. Below it, the order moves. Claneo was named in 26 buyer-question answers but only 9 short-keyword answers. Aufgesang ranks fourth on buyer questions (15) but eighteenth on short keywords (2). Semtrix shows the opposite: joint second on short keywords (9) and seventeenth on buyer questions (2). Ostend Digital was named only for short keywords.

Buyer questions produced more brands per prompt (13.8 across three engines, against 11.8 for short keywords). Suchhelden was named in 21 short-keyword prompts and 18 buyer-question prompts. Any agency ranking that does not publish its prompt list can be engineered by choosing the prompts. Ours is published in full below.

Main comparison of the German shortlist

The interactive table holds the full shortlist. Switch the view for AI visibility, Google, traffic, links and keywords; click a heading to sort.

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study562661472
Claneoclaneo.com35307660
Seokratieseokratie.de281059664
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de2160341
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de1735560
Aufgesangaufgesang.de17192559
SUMAXsumax.de16278160
DREIKONdreikon.de151051658
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de151121162
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de14163633
morefiremore-fire.com13463164
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing1273652
seosupportseosupport.de1288743
adMatesadmates.de11210327
Semtrixsemtrix.de1189960
seowerkseowerk.de10331935
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de10682353
Ostend Digitalostend.digital6982354
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de45725276
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com31092656

¹ Dashboard mentions use AmICited’s definitions and list only the top 50 brands; a dash means the agency was outside that list, not zero.

Who wins German organic traffic?

Estimated monthly organic visits from Germany
SEO-Küche 57,252*
Suchhelden 26,614
Online Solutions Group 11,211
Löwenstark 10,926
Seokratie 10,596
DREIKON 10,516
Ostend Digital 9,823
SaphirSolution 6,823
morefire 4,631
seowerk 3,319

Shortlist, own domains, subdomains included. SEO-Küche's figure is dominated by glossary and blog pages.

Source: Ahrefs, average volume mode, 17 Nov 2026

*SEO-Küche is a special case. Of the 54,819 estimated German visits on its 250 strongest pages, 37,910 land on glossary (“lexikon”) entries, led by one page answering whether Googlemail and Gmail are the same (15,884), and 16,085 on blog and guide pages. That traffic is real, but it is not demand for agency services, which is why we did not choose SEO-Küche as the reference domain.

Suchhelden leads on agency-relevant traffic: 1,267 German keywords, 610 of them in the top three. Its homepage ranks for “seo agentur”, and service and city pages fill most of its top pages; glossary pages bring about a fifth of its estimated traffic and free tools, such as translator pages, under a tenth. Online Solutions Group (11,211) and DREIKON (10,516) follow with large content inventories.

Traffic and AI naming overlap only partly. Löwenstark (10,926 visits) and Ostend Digital (9,823) are in the top seven for German traffic but were named in 3 and 6 AI answers. Netzbekannt and Hecht ins Gefecht have fewer than 700 estimated German visits each, yet were named in 21 and 17 answers.

Ahrefs Domain Rating is a relative score of a domain’s backlink profile on a 100-point scale. Referring domains count unique linking sites.

AgencyAhrefs DRReferring domainsAI answers naming it
SEO-Küche765,5824
Suchhelden722,90256
Seokratie642,84328
morefire642,48913
Online Solutions Group621,83515
Claneo603,79135
Semtrix602,97011
Hecht ins Gefecht601,62117
Löwenstark563,5273
Netzbekannt4190921
adMates2783011

Source: Ahrefs batch analysis, 17 Nov 2026; AmICited snapshot.

Links alone don’t explain AI naming. Suchhelden combines a strong profile with the most AI answers, but SEO-Küche (DR 76) and Löwenstark (3,527 referring domains) were rarely named. Netzbekannt has a mid-range DR of 41 and the fourth-most AI answers. We don’t judge link quality from these aggregates; a buyer who cares should ask the agency for its own link-building rules.

How technically sound are the sites?

Core Web Vitals: what real Chrome users experience

AmICited imports Chrome UX Report field data (LCP, INP and CLS at the 75th percentile of real Chrome visits) for every tracked domain. We read the values below from AmICited’s Competitors view on 17 November 2026. Google’s thresholds for “good” are LCP up to 2.5 s, INP up to 200 ms and CLS up to 0.1 ( Web Vitals).

15 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com2600700.02
Claneoclaneo.com2500620.01
Ostend Digitalostend.digital20001120.01
seowerkseowerk.de2000—0.08
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de19001670.05
adMatesadmates.de1800860
DREIKONdreikon.de1600650.21
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de16001040.01
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de1300—0.06
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing1200620.03
Seokratieseokratie.de900680.1
morefiremore-fire.com900780.02
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study700630.01
SUMAXsumax.de700760
Semtrixsemtrix.de600770

15 of the 20 shortlisted agencies have field data, and 11 of them pass all three metrics. Semtrix (LCP 0.6 s), Suchhelden and SUMAX (0.7 s each) are the fastest. Two fail: DREIKON on layout stability (CLS 0.21) and Löwenstark narrowly on loading (LCP 2.6 s). SUCHMEISTEREI and seowerk lack an INP value. The five agencies added after the registry (Netzbekannt, Aufgesang, Hecht ins Gefecht, seosupport and SaphirSolution) were not tracked in AmICited, so they have no field values here; that is “not measured”, not “fast” or “slow”. Across the whole registry, 77 of 101 sites have field data and 51 pass.

Lab and field data disagree, sometimes sharply. Ostend Digital scores 48 in our Lighthouse lab test with a lab LCP of 14.7 s, yet real Chrome users see its main content in 2.0 s and it passes all three field metrics. Löwenstark’s lab LCP is 18.0 s against a field LCP of 2.6 s. Real users’ devices, networks, caches and the pages they actually land on differ from one emulated phone, which is why we report both and rank neither as the truth.

Lighthouse: one machine’s lab measurement

Lighthouse ran three mobile lab passes per shortlisted homepage (Lighthouse 12.6.1, emulated mid-range Android phone, simulated throttling) from one workstation on 17 November 2026. We report the median; for Online Solutions Group and seowerk one run failed on our machine, so their figure is the median of two. Lab scores depend on the test machine and network, so they compare sites under identical conditions; they don’t replace real-user data.

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de9919650
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de962274110
SUMAXsumax.de932490164
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing88349426
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study8632710
seowerkseowerk.de784222119
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de764531135
Seokratieseokratie.de7464810
morefiremore-fire.com732926654
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de725954.531
DREIKONdreikon.de68612597
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de686036178
Semtrixsemtrix.de664109734
adMatesadmates.de654389737
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de645162546
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com6017957114
Claneoclaneo.com575320607
seosupportseosupport.de5216306530
Aufgesangaufgesang.de509854652
Ostend Digitalostend.digital4814665820

Hecht ins Gefecht (99), Netzbekannt (96) and SUMAX (93) have the fastest homepages in the lab, and they are the only three with a lab LCP of 2.5 seconds or less. Suchhelden is fifth with 86 (LCP 3.3 s). Several agencies that sell technical SEO fall well short: Ostend Digital (48), Aufgesang (50), seosupport (52) and Claneo (57). In total, 14 of the 20 homepages have a lab LCP above 4 seconds. Layout stability is good almost everywhere (CLS 0.03 or lower on 19 of 20), and 18 of 20 score 92 or higher in Lighthouse’s SEO category.

Speed doesn’t predict AI naming in this sample. Netzbekannt and Hecht ins Gefecht combine fast homepages with frequent naming, but Claneo, the second-most-named agency, scores 57, and Suchhelden leads AI naming with a mid-table lab score. The Lighthouse documentation explains what each category measures.

Direct HTML observations

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
adMatesadmates.de20012
Aufgesangaufgesang.de20021
Claneoclaneo.com20011
DREIKONdreikon.de20011
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de20011
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing20011
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com20013
morefiremore-fire.com20011
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de20014
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de20015
Ostend Digitalostend.digital20018
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de20015
Semtrixsemtrix.de20024
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de20012
Seokratieseokratie.de20013
seosupportseosupport.de20001
seowerkseowerk.de20011
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study20011
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de20012
SUMAXsumax.de20012

99 of 101 registry homepages returned HTTP 200 to our bounded fetch; two returned 403. All 20 shortlisted homepages responded. 17 have exactly one H1; Aufgesang and Semtrix have two, and seosupport none in its static HTML. All 20 publish JSON-LD on the homepage; Ostend Digital has eight blocks.

Robots.txt and AI crawlers: 17 of the 101 registry sites name AI crawlers in robots.txt. Among the shortlist, SUMAX and Netzbekannt address GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ChatGPT-User, PerplexityBot or Claude crawlers explicitly. Naming a bot is not the same as blocking it; check the AI accessibility report for what each rule actually allows.

llms.txt: AmICited’s llms.txt check scores Suchhelden, Löwenstark, morefire, SUMAX, seowerk and Semtrix at 0.9 or higher. Claneo, DREIKON, SUCHMEISTEREI, Ostend Digital and SEO-Küche scored 0; the five agencies added after the registry were not checked. Claneo is the second-most-named agency without one, so an llms.txt file is clearly not a prerequisite for being named.

Sitemaps: how much content is actually discoverable?

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de6847partial
DREIKONdreikon.de2141ok
morefiremore-fire.com1337ok
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de1253ok
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de1238ok
Ostend Digitalostend.digital1029partial
Seokratieseokratie.de983ok
Aufgesangaufgesang.de472ok
seosupportseosupport.de454partial
seowerkseowerk.de449ok
Claneoclaneo.com442ok
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study398ok
Semtrixsemtrix.de396ok
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com344partial
SUMAXsumax.de239ok
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing214ok
adMatesadmates.de180ok
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de135ok
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de72ok
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de50ok

86 of the 101 registry sites returned a complete sitemap inventory within our limits, 12 a partial one and 3 none. Sitemap size varies by a factor of more than 100 within the shortlist: Online Solutions Group lists at least 6,847 URLs (our crawl stopped at its limits), DREIKON 2,141 and morefire 1,337, while Netzbekannt lists 72 and Hecht ins Gefecht 50.

Size is not the same as reach. Hecht ins Gefecht’s 50 URLs were cited in 16 AI answers, more than any other shortlisted agency except Suchhelden. Online Solutions Group’s inventory is mostly blog posts (about 4,700 URLs contain “blog”). DREIKON’s 2,141 URLs include English and Dutch sections of about 710 URLs each, which is also why less than half of its estimated organic traffic comes from Germany.

Freshness: real updates or changed timestamps?

The lastmod value in a sitemap is a declaration, not proof of an edit. Three patterns stand out:

  • Suchhelden declares every one of its 398 sitemap URLs as modified in the last 30 days, using only 7 distinct timestamps. That pattern usually comes from automatic regeneration, not from 398 edits, so it tells crawlers little about which pages actually changed. SUMAX shows a similar pattern: 239 URLs with 4 distinct values.
  • Claneo declared 378 of its 442 URLs as modified in the last 30 days, with 441 distinct timestamps. That fits a site that is actively editing, though the dates alone can’t prove it.
  • Seokratie (median lastmod age 1,019 days), seosupport (1,275 days) and SaphirSolution (834 days) give search engines and AI crawlers little freshness signal. Seokratie still publishes current guides, so its sitemap probably understates its activity. See content freshness.

Which topics do the URL inventories emphasise?

Counting URL words reveals what each agency invests in:

AgencyDominant URL termsGEO / KI / AI URLs
DREIKONlp, marketing, agency, agentur101 KI/AI, 27 GEO
seowerknews, agentur, seo, ki85 KI/AI, 48 GEO
Claneoblog, seo, marketing, folge (podcast)38 KI/AI, 74 GEO
morefiremarketing, wissen, podcast, blog88 KI/AI, 13 GEO
Online Solutions Groupblog, glossar, google, agentur69 KI/AI, 17 GEO
Semtrixlexikon, seo, blog, agentur46 KI/AI, 26 GEO
SEO-Kücheblog, lexikon, google, ratgeber45 KI/AI, 9 GEO
Suchheldenseo, google, agentur, tools22 KI/AI, 20 GEO
Hecht ins Gefechtseo, geo, google, llm12 KI/AI, 4 GEO

Glossaries (“lexikon”, “glossar”) are everywhere among the high-traffic agencies: SEO-Küche, Online Solutions Group, SaphirSolution, Ostend Digital, Semtrix and SUMAX all run one. But the agency pages AI cites most are not glossary entries. They are rankings of agencies, which match the shape of a buyer’s question exactly. That fits a broader pattern in what ChatGPT cites, but it isn’t proof that list pages cause citations, and an agency ranking its own competitors is not a neutral source.

Agency profiles: evidence and open questions

Each profile separates what we measured from what the agency says about itself. Claims are quoted from official pages fetched on 17 November 2026.

Suchhelden: the AI favourite, strongest in Google’s engines

The reference domain. Named in 56 AI answers and cited in 39, both the highest of any agency in the study, with the most classic Google result sets of the shortlist (8 of 100) and the highest German traffic among agency-service sites (26,614 a month). AI Overviews accounts for more than half of its naming (29 answers); ChatGPT for 13. Suchhelden GmbH (Osnabrück, HRB 208418) claims “14+ Jahren Erfahrung und über 4.000 betreuten Projekten”, an iBusiness award for Q3/2026 and its own prompt-analysis software, and its founders published a book on GEO. It publishes client figures such as “+3.175 % Sichtbarkeit und +642 % Nennungsrate in KI-Antworten” without baselines on the pages we read. What to check: the baseline, period and tool behind each percentage, and how its own agency ranking is compiled.

Claneo: ChatGPT’s first choice

Named in 35 answers, more in ChatGPT (16) than any other agency, but cited in only 10. The Berlin agency (HRB 192473) calls itself a “mehrfach ausgezeichnete Agentur für internationales SEO, GEO & Content Marketing” founded in 2017, with “über 80 Expert:innen” working in “mehr als zehn Sprachen”, and offers an “AI (GEO) Quick Check”. Its sitemap has the most GEO URLs of the shortlist (74), but no llms.txt. What to check: which of the 80 people work on your account, and what the GEO check measures.

Seokratie: balanced across engines

Named in 28 answers, spread evenly across ChatGPT (7), AI Overviews (11) and AI Mode (10), with 10,596 estimated German visits. The Munich agency (HRB 297073) says “Wir machen SEO seit 2008”, positions itself for “B2B und Industrie” and notes that founder Julian Dziki wrote “SEO für Dummies”. It has a subsidiary in Kitzbühel, Tyrol. Its case studies cite “Steigerung der organischen Sichtbarkeit um fast 700%”. What to check: comparable B2B cases and the period behind the percentages.

Netzbekannt: named by ChatGPT, invisible on Google

Named in 21 answers, 15 of them by ChatGPT, without appearing in any recorded Google result and with about 600 estimated German visits. Netzbekannt GmbH (Berlin, HRB 193217 B) calls itself an “SEO-/GEO-Agentur aus Berlin”, claims “über 10 Jahre SEO- und LLM-Expertise” and offers a free GEO analysis. Its homepage also notes that the managing directors wrote and sang the company song. What to check: where ChatGPT gets its information about the agency, and references in your sector.

Hecht ins Gefecht: a small site with the most-cited ranking

Named in 17 answers and cited in 16, almost all through its own list of the ten most visible SEO agencies in Germany, which puts Hecht ins Gefecht first. The Bremen agency (HRB 42926) focuses on ecommerce SEO and GEO, cites “212 Bewertungen bei ProvenExpert” and describes its GEO approach as “eine eindeutige Entität, Erwähnungen auf vielen unabhängigen Websites und eine Messung mit klaren Kennzahlen”. Its sitemap has 50 URLs. What to check: the method behind its ranking, and client results outside its own visibility.

Aufgesang: strong on buyer questions

Named in 17 answers, 15 of them for buyer questions and only 2 for short keywords. The Hannover agency (HRB 212463) says it has “über 20 Jahre Erfahrung in Online-Marketing & PR”, calls itself “eine der ersten Agenturen für Generative Engine Optimierung” and states that its running client projects raised their visibility “im Schnitt um rund 82 % im Jahr” from 2023 to 2025. What to check: which metric “Sichtbarkeit” means and how the average was calculated.

SUMAX and DREIKON: Google’s engines over ChatGPT

SUMAX (Dortmund) was named in 16 answers, 12 of them by AI Overviews, and appeared in Google’s results for 5 prompts, 3 in the top three. It says it has worked “seit 2005” with “über 50 Mitarbeitende” and “28 eigene Anwendungen”, and publishes case results such as “+425 % Conversions”. DREIKON (Münster) was named in 15 answers and cited in 14; all 5 of its Google result sets are in the top three. Its own ranking of the best SEO agencies puts DREIKON first, with a transparency note, and lists its price “ab 1.000 €/Mon.” It fails the CLS threshold in field data (0.21). What to check: for both, what the case figures were measured against.

Online Solutions Group: one company, two brands

Named in 15 answers under its own name, with 11,211 estimated German visits and the largest sitemap of the shortlist. The Munich company also runs seoagentur.de, whose imprint names Online Solutions Group GmbH; that brand was named in another 12 answers. We count them separately because the engines do, but a buyer comparing offers should know they are one supplier. OSG claims “über 1.000 Projekte”, BVDW certification for SEO and SEA, and a “Performance Suite” that “kennt über 10 Mio. echte Nutzerfragen”. What to check: which brand will sign the contract and who will do the work.

SUCHMEISTEREI, JSH Marketing, seosupport, adMates, Semtrix, seowerk and SaphirSolution

  • SUCHMEISTEREI (Berlin): named in 14 answers, a Google Premier Partner by its own account, with a GEO and KI agency page.
  • JSH Marketing (Munich): named in 12 answers; founder “macht SEO seit 2008, als Agentur gibt es uns seit 2016”. Publishes the clearest price guidance: “Unter 700 Euro pro Monat ist keine substanzielle Arbeit finanzierbar”, with typical ranges “zwischen 900 und 15.000 Euro pro Monat”.
  • seosupport (Berlin and Munich): named in 12 answers, claims “50 Mitarbeiter in Berlin und München” and work “seit 2006”; it also sells Wikipedia article creation “ab 1.500 €”.
  • adMates (Munich): named in 11 answers, 7 by AI Overviews; retainers “starten bei 1.500€ / Monat für lokale Unternehmen”.
  • Semtrix (Düsseldorf): named in 11 answers, part of the Eskimoz group, which won “Best Large Integrated Search Agency” at the European Search Awards 2026 according to Semtrix.
  • seowerk (Munich): named in 10 answers but second for Google result sets (6); publishes GEO case studies for a law firm and a hotel.
  • SaphirSolution (Niederkassel): named in 10 answers, claims “70+ Digital-Spezialisten” and asks for “mindestens 1500€ pro Monat” in budget.

SEO-Küche, Löwenstark, Ostend Digital and morefire

These four have strong own-site traffic but modest AI naming. SEO-Küche (Kolbermoor) has the most German traffic and the highest DR (76), but was named in only 4 answers; its pages are cited mainly for GEO and SEO guides. Löwenstark (Braunschweig) says it has been “seit 2001 spezialisiert auf SEO” with “25+ SEO-Expertinnen und -Experten” and offers an SEO audit “ab 999 €”; 3 answers. Ostend Digital (Stuttgart) publishes many cases ("+360%" leads for Putzmeister) and was named 6 times, all for short keywords. morefire (Cologne) was named in 13 answers but never cited. For these, the gap between own-site strength and AI naming is the finding, not a verdict on their work.

Evergreen Media: an Austrian agency competing in Germany

Evergreen Media AR GmbH is registered in Innsbruck, Austria, and runs evergreen.media for the German market. It has 13,374 estimated German visits, appeared in Google’s results for 10 prompts and was cited in 21 AI answers, most often through its GEO guide, but was named in only 10. We keep it as a control because German buyers will meet it in search, just as the Austrian edition kept Suchhelden as a German control.

The revenue leaders are almost invisible in this prompt set

Plan.Net, ]init[, valantic and mgm technology partners rank first, third, fifth and seventh in the iBusiness Internetagentur-Ranking 2026. They were named in 0–3 AI answers each. Their business is large transformation and development projects, not the SEO and GEO questions we asked. Size and AI visibility for SEO queries are different things.

Who demonstrates international organic reach?

20 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.de65858572523372
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the study2973026614317
DREIKONdreikon.de2219610516831
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.de15357112111311
Löwenstarkloewenstark.com1461510926862
Seokratieseokratie.de1160210596358
Ostend Digitalostend.digital10518982394
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.de7018682362
morefiremore-fire.com57224631294
SUMAXsumax.de4170278159
seowerkseowerk.de3815331925
Claneoclaneo.com3476307649
adMatesadmates.de2266210332
Aufgesangaufgesang.de2056192527
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.de177016360
Semtrixsemtrix.de104689916
seosupportseosupport.de10078871
JSH Marketingjsh.marketing8227360
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.de764603127
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.de3653552

Most German agencies are domestic: for 15 of the 20 shortlisted sites, Germany accounts for more than 80% of estimated organic traffic. The clear exception is DREIKON, with 22,196 estimated visits worldwide, only 10,516 of them from Germany, and English and Dutch site sections. Online Solutions Group, Löwenstark and SUMAX draw a quarter to a third of their traffic from outside Germany. In Austria, SEO-Küche (3,372 visits a month) and Online Solutions Group (1,311) have the largest estimated audiences.

What Suchhelden should do next

Suchhelden is the strongest German agency in this study on every AI measure and on agency-relevant traffic, and its homepage passes all three Core Web Vitals. The gap is ChatGPT, where it was named in 13 answers, fewer than Claneo (16) and Netzbekannt (15). On the evidence, these steps follow:

  1. Close the ChatGPT gap through the sources ChatGPT cites. ChatGPT cited agenturtipp.de in 44 answers, Dr. Web in 23, Sortlist in 14, Feedbax in 12, and selbstaendig-im-netz.de and deutschlands-experten.de in 9 each. Complete, current and reviewed profiles there are the most direct lever.
  2. Make its own ranking defensible. Suchhelden’s most-cited page is its list of the best German SEO agencies, which starts with Suchhelden. A visible method note and disclosure, as DREIKON adds to its list, would make that citation harder to dismiss.
  3. Fix the sitemap’s freshness signal. All 398 URLs carry a lastmod from the last 30 days but only 7 distinct values. Dates that reflect real edits help search engines and AI crawlers prioritise recrawls.
  4. Publish baselines with case studies. Figures such as “+3.175 % Sichtbarkeit” need a starting value, period and measurement tool before an AI engine or a buyer can rely on them.
  5. Track the engines separately. Suchhelden was named by all three engines for only three prompts (“Beste SEO Agentur in Deutschland?”, “Welche Agentur macht GEO-Optimierung in Deutschland?” and “Welche Agentur hilft bei KI-Sichtbarkeit in Deutschland?”). Recurring prompts per engine in AmICited’s AI visibility tracking would show whether the changes move the numbers.

Speed is not the problem: real Chrome users see Suchhelden’s main homepage content in 0.7 seconds (Chrome UX Report, p75). AmICited’s Performance impact charts below show where Suchhelden’s pages sit among the pages each engine cites; that is an association, not proof that speed drives citations.

About the publisher: AmICited.com in Ahrefs

AmICited publishes this benchmark. It is software, not an agency, so it appears in none of the rankings above. In the 300 German AI answers, amicited.com was neither named nor cited, which is expected: every prompt asks for an agency, not a tool.

For readers who want to see the publisher’s own footprint, these are the Ahrefs captures from our Slovak edition, taken on 3 November 2026. We did not take new ones for Germany. The domain was registered on 8 December 2025 ( Verisign RDAP), so it was 339 days old on this study’s snapshot date.

Ahrefs and this benchmark measure different things. Ahrefs counts responses to its own questions, in its own countries and index, so its 786 responses cannot be compared with the 300 German answers measured here. A young domain earning positions and citations is a useful counterexample to “you need years of history”, but it says nothing about leads, revenue or the work an agency would do for you.

Which keywords and prompts did we use?

The 60 short keywords come from Ahrefs Keywords Explorer for Germany, chosen by relevance to agency services and by volume (average monthly searches, retrieved 17 November 2026): from “content marketing” (39,000) and “seo agentur” (8,700) down to “seo und geo” (400). The 40 buyer questions are short and in everyday German, and none mentions an agency. Every prompt ran in AmICited with country Germany, one-time schedule, on ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode.

100 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
content marketingshort Ahrefs keywords39000
seo agenturshort Ahrefs keywords8700
webdesign agenturshort Ahrefs keywords8000
suchmaschinenoptimierungshort Ahrefs keywords7500
seo beratungshort Ahrefs keywords6900
online marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords6700
werbeagenturshort Ahrefs keywords6400
performance marketingshort Ahrefs keywords5300
social media agenturshort Ahrefs keywords4600
marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords4300
google ads agenturshort Ahrefs keywords3700
seo optimierungshort Ahrefs keywords3300
seo agentur berlinshort Ahrefs keywords3100
local seoshort Ahrefs keywords2900
digitalagenturshort Ahrefs keywords2800
seo agentur essenshort Ahrefs keywords2700
seo experteshort Ahrefs keywords2600
sea agenturshort Ahrefs keywords2400
seo berlinshort Ahrefs keywords2100
linkbuilding agenturshort Ahrefs keywords2100
digital marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords2100
seo agentur münchenshort Ahrefs keywords2000
seo auditshort Ahrefs keywords2000
geo optimierungshort Ahrefs keywords1900
geo agenturshort Ahrefs keywords1700
content marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords1700
seo preiseshort Ahrefs keywords1600
performance marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords1600
suchmaschinenoptimierung berlinshort Ahrefs keywords1500
online marketing agentur düsseldorfshort Ahrefs keywords1500
online marketing agentur nürnbergshort Ahrefs keywords1500
geo seoshort Ahrefs keywords1400
seo agentur hamburgshort Ahrefs keywords1400
seo agentur kölnshort Ahrefs keywords1400
seo beratershort Ahrefs keywords1300
ki seoshort Ahrefs keywords1300
seo agentur stuttgartshort Ahrefs keywords1300
webdesign agentur berlinshort Ahrefs keywords1200
suchmaschinenoptimierung agenturshort Ahrefs keywords1200
local seo agenturshort Ahrefs keywords1200
social media marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords1100
seo geoshort Ahrefs keywords1100
seo betreuungshort Ahrefs keywords1100
suchmaschinenoptimierung agentur münchenshort Ahrefs keywords900
seo frankfurtshort Ahrefs keywords900
wordpress seo agenturshort Ahrefs keywords900
werbeagentur düsseldorfshort Ahrefs keywords800
ki seo agenturshort Ahrefs keywords800
seo agentur mannheimshort Ahrefs keywords800
online marketing agentur berlinshort Ahrefs keywords700
b2b marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords700
seo agentur düsseldorfshort Ahrefs keywords700
seo agentur nürnbergshort Ahrefs keywords700
shopware seo agenturshort Ahrefs keywords700
beste seo agenturshort Ahrefs keywords700
google ads agentur münchenshort Ahrefs keywords600
seo agentur dortmundshort Ahrefs keywords600
geo agentur münchenshort Ahrefs keywords500
ki marketing agenturshort Ahrefs keywords450
seo und geoshort Ahrefs keywords400
Welche Agentur hilft bei KI-Sichtbarkeit in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Webdesign Agentur in Berlin macht auch SEO?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht Performance Marketing in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur bietet SEO und GEO aus einer Hand?buyer questions—
Welche Agenturen messen KI-Sichtbarkeit in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur sorgt für Empfehlungen in ChatGPT?buyer questions—
Welche SEO Agentur eignet sich für kleine Unternehmen?buyer questions—
Welche SEO Agentur in Berlin hat gute Bewertungen?buyer questions—
Welche SEO Agentur in Deutschland hat transparente Preise?buyer questions—
Welche Social Media Agentur in Berlin ist gut?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht LinkedIn Marketing in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur kombiniert SEO und Google Ads?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht SEO für WordPress Websites?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur schreibt SEO Texte in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Wer macht technisches SEO in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur hilft beim Relaunch ohne SEO-Verlust?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht Linkbuilding in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht Hotel Online Marketing in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht Online Marketing für Ärzte?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht B2B SEO in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Wer optimiert das Google Unternehmensprofil in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur hilft bei lokalem SEO in Berlin?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht SEO für Shopify Shops?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht SEO für Onlineshops in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Gute SEO Agentur in Frankfurt?buyer questions—
Welche SEO Agentur in Köln ist empfehlenswert?buyer questions—
Welche SEO Agentur in München ist empfehlenswert?buyer questions—
Welche SEO Agentur in Hamburg ist gut?buyer questions—
Beste Digitalagentur in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Beste Google Ads Agentur in Berlin?buyer questions—
Welche SEO Agentur in Bayern ist empfehlenswert?buyer questions—
Wie finde ich eine seriöse SEO Agentur?buyer questions—
Was kostet ein SEO Audit in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Was kostet Google Ads Betreuung pro Monat?buyer questions—
Was kostet eine SEO Agentur in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur hilft bei Google AI Overviews?buyer questions—
Wer optimiert Websites für ChatGPT in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Agentur macht GEO-Optimierung in Deutschland?buyer questions—
Welche Online Marketing Agentur in Berlin ist empfehlenswert?buyer questions—
Beste SEO Agentur in Deutschland?buyer questions—

The complete competitor registry

All 131 measured hosts: the reference domain, 100 registered competitors and 30 agencies that AI named but the registry missed.

131 records · click a heading to sort

Source: AmICited, Ahrefs and public websites · Nov 12, 2026. Dash = unavailable.
Suchheldensuchhelden.deReference domain of the studyverified shortlist56
Claneoclaneo.comverified shortlist35
Seokratieseokratie.deverified shortlist28
Netzbekanntnetzbekannt.deverified shortlist21
Hecht ins Gefechthechtinsgefecht.deverified shortlist17
Aufgesangaufgesang.deverified shortlist17
SUMAXsumax.deverified shortlist16
DREIKONdreikon.deverified shortlist15
Online Solutions Grouponlinesolutionsgroup.deverified shortlist15
SUCHMEISTEREIsuchmeisterei.deverified shortlist14
morefiremore-fire.comverified shortlist13
seoagentur.deseoagentur.detracked candidate; scope unverified12
JSH Marketingjsh.marketingverified shortlist12
seosupportseosupport.deverified shortlist12
adMatesadmates.deverified shortlist11
Semtrixsemtrix.deverified shortlist11
Evergreen Mediaevergreen.mediaAustrian agency (Innsbruck) with .media site (control)10
seowerkseowerk.deverified shortlist10
SaphirSolutionsaphirsolution.deverified shortlist10
Specht GmbHspecht-gmbh.deAI-named, not in registry9
SEOAgentsseoagents.detracked candidate; scope unverified8
Peak Acepeakace.agencytracked candidate; scope unverified8
SEO Erfolgseo-erfolg.deAI-named, not in registry8
dskomdskom.deAI-named, not in registry8
Ucentric Mediaucentric-media.detracked candidate; scope unverified7
SEOeffektseoeffekt.detracked candidate; scope unverified7
Locally Visiblelocally-visible.detracked candidate; scope unverified7
Local SEO Agentur GmbHlocal-seo-agentur.comtracked candidate; scope unverified7
rankeffectrankeffect.deAI-named, not in registry7
Ostend Digitalostend.digitalverified shortlist6
SEO Revolutionseo-revolution.comtracked candidate; scope unverified6
arise Online Marketingarise-onlinemarketing.detracked candidate; scope unverified6
adojoadojo.deAI-named, not in registry6
Bloofusionbloofusion.deAI-named, not in registry6
Suchmaschinenmaklersuchmaschinenmakler.deAI-named, not in registry6
Schild Rothschild-roth.comAI-named, not in registry6
DTILEdtile.deAI-named, not in registry6
famefactfamefact.comAI-named, not in registry6
ZweiDigitalzweidigital.detracked candidate; scope unverified5
Hanserankinghanseranking.detracked candidate; scope unverified5
.brandcombrandcom.detracked candidate; scope unverified5
eMindedeminded.detracked candidate; scope unverified5
Die SEA-Expertensea-experten.detracked candidate; scope unverified5
SearchWelt24searchwelt24.deAI-named, not in registry5
Agentur Emilianagentur-emilian.deAI-named, not in registry5
SEO-Kücheseo-kueche.deverified shortlist4
eologyeology.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
schmidtmediaschmidtmedia.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
suxeedosuxeedo.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
Trustfactorytrustfactory.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
AdPointadpoint.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
clicks digitalclicks.digitaltracked candidate; scope unverified4
Digitalagentendigitalagenten.comtracked candidate; scope unverified4
performanceLiebeperformanceliebe.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
effektoreffektor.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
netspiritsnetspirits.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
webdesign berlinwebdesign-berlin.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
SEMFLOWsemflow.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
KlickPilotenklickpiloten.detracked candidate; scope unverified4
Beyond Mediabeyond-media.deAI-named, not in registry4
ABAKUS Internet Marketingabakus-internet-marketing.deAI-named, not in registry4
Backlinkedbacklinked.comAI-named, not in registry4
TRYSEOtryseo.deAI-named, not in registry4
eom.deeom.deAI-named, not in registry4
SEPHIROTECsephirotec.deAI-named, not in registry4
NX Digitalnxdigital.deAI-named, not in registry4
Löwenstarkloewenstark.comverified shortlist3
Optimerchoptimerch.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
WEBneowebneo.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
WEDEONwedeon.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
FAIRRANKfairrank.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
SEO Agentur Hamburgseoagentur-hamburg.comtracked candidate; scope unverified3
SUMA SEARCHsumasearch.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
arboroarboro.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
Marketing Nativesmarketing-natives.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
expericsexperics.detracked candidate; scope unverified3
SEO-Retterseo-retter.deAI-named, not in registry3
AN Digitalan-digital.comAI-named, not in registry3
internetwarriorsinternetwarriors.deAI-named, not in registry3
SEOthinkingseothinking.deAI-named, not in registry3
Plan.Netplan.netlargest by revenue, iBusiness Internetagentur-Ranking 2026 (control)3
Seiten-Werkseiten-werk.comtracked candidate; scope unverified2
SUNZINETsunzinet.comtracked candidate; scope unverified2
Advideraadvidera.comtracked candidate; scope unverified2
ECONSOReconsor.detracked candidate; scope unverified2
SMART LEMONsmartlemon.detracked candidate; scope unverified2
IronSharkironshark.detracked candidate; scope unverified2
Think11think11.detracked candidate; scope unverified2
SEO-Agentur Essenseo-agentur-essen.detracked candidate; scope unverified2
JUNGMUTjungmut.comtracked candidate; scope unverified2
Contundacontunda.detracked candidate; scope unverified2
diva-e Conclusiondiva-e.comtracked candidate; scope unverified2
]init[init.delargest by revenue, iBusiness Internetagentur-Ranking 2026 (control)2
valanticvalantic.comlargest by revenue, iBusiness Internetagentur-Ranking 2026 (control)2
creationellcreationell.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
advertaceadvertace.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
digitalagentur.berlindigitalagentur.berlintracked candidate; scope unverified1
netgradenetgrade.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
pilotpilot.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
Chris and friendschris-andfriends.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
webnetzwebnetz.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
artundweiseartundweise.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
Projecterprojecter.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
Koch Essenkoch-essen.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
hohrisinghohrising.comtracked candidate; scope unverified1
netkinnetkin.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
Finnwaafinnwaa.detracked candidate; scope unverified1
krick.comkrick.comtracked candidate; scope unverified0
JUNG&BANSEjungundbanse.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
8mylez8mylez.comtracked candidate; scope unverified0
7thSENSE7thsense.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
REAL.real-marketing.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
FLE-mediafle-media.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
Jung&Billigjungundbillig.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
SEOMATIKseomatik.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
Pitch Thispitchthis.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
Dein Social Mediadeinsocialmedia.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
SEO Agentur Berlinseo-agentur-berlin.mediatracked candidate; scope unverified0
die mainagenturdie-mainagentur.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
AWEOSaweos.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
schoene neue kindersnk.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
atravaatrava.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
glow Berlinglow-berlin.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
MEDIAHAUSmediahaus.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
alto.alto.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
SEO Marketing GmbHseo-marketing.koelntracked candidate; scope unverified0
imc marketing & consultdigitalagentur-ecommerce.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
netzgoldnetzgold.nettracked candidate; scope unverified0
Agentur Gerhardagentur-gerhard.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
herold medienheroldmedien.detracked candidate; scope unverified0
mgm technology partnersmgm-tp.comlargest by revenue, iBusiness Internetagentur-Ranking 2026 (control)0

How to assess an agency before signing

Exact prompts behind any AI-visibility claim.
Who wrote the ranking.
Mentions, citations, visits and leads kept apart.
A comparable client case with a baseline.
The price and what it buys.
Their own measurable visibility.

If you run an agency yourself, AmICited for agencies covers how to report AI visibility to clients with exact prompts and engine splits, and AI share of voice explains the metric used here.

The takeaway

Germany’s agency market looks different depending on who you ask. Google shows directories, AI Overviews rewards Suchhelden, ChatGPT spreads its answers between Claneo, Netzbekannt and Suchhelden, and agencies’ own rankings of agencies feed all three. No single number, whether traffic, DR or AI mentions, picks the right agency for a specific project.

For buyers, the useful move is to ask every shortlisted agency for the same evidence: exact prompts, engines and dates for AI claims, the method behind any ranking, baselines for case studies, and the scope behind the price. For agencies, the data shows where the gaps are, engine by engine. We’ll repeat this benchmark with recurring prompts so the next edition can show trends, not just a snapshot.

Limitations

  • One run per prompt and engine. AI answers vary between runs; this is a snapshot, not a stable ranking.
  • The prompt set favours SEO, GEO and online-marketing services in German. It does not measure branding, development or PR agencies on their own terms.
  • Brand matching merges spellings with an automatic key plus a hand-checked alias list. 238 brand spellings, mostly small agencies and freelancers outside the registry, could not be resolved and are not credited to anyone.
  • Five shortlisted agencies (Netzbekannt, Aufgesang, Hecht ins Gefecht, seosupport and SaphirSolution) were added after the AmICited run, so AmICited’s dashboard, authority, llms.txt and field Web Vitals views don’t cover them. Their AI naming, Ahrefs, crawl and Lighthouse data are complete.
  • Ahrefs traffic and keywords are modelled estimates, retrieved on 17 November 2026, five days after the AI snapshot. Country attribution is not buyer intent.
  • Sitemap counts are discovered URLs within a bounded crawl, not indexed pages. lastmod is a declaration.
  • Field Core Web Vitals come from the Chrome UX Report through AmICited (p75, origin or homepage level, read on 17 November 2026); sites with too little Chrome traffic have none. Lighthouse results are lab data from one machine.
  • Screenshots are actual AmICited interface captures from 17 November 2026, cropped to remove navigation and account details. Interface totals (for example 1,612 citations) use AmICited’s own definitions and can differ from our one-per-answer counts.
  • Supplier claims were read on official pages and are not independently verified.
  • The shortlist is an editorial selection with an imprint check, not a certification of quality.

Found this useful? Pass it on.

LinkedIn X

Frequently asked questions

Arshia is an AI Workflow Engineer at FlowHunt. With a background in computer science and a passion for AI, he specializes in creating efficient workflows that integrate AI tools into everyday tasks, enhancing productivity and creativity.

Arshia Kahani
Arshia Kahani
AI Workflow Engineer